Propylene glycol (PG) and ethylene glycol (EG) look almost interchangeable. Both are colorless, slightly viscous liquids with a faint sweet taste. Both are fully miscible with water, and both work as solvents and freezing-point depressants. They show up in many of the same applications: antifreeze, deicing fluids, heat-transfer systems, polyester synthesis.
The one thing that genuinely separates them is toxicity. EG is acutely toxic, and a confirmed developmental toxicant under California Prop 65. PG is generally recognized as safe (GRAS) by the FDA for food use, with an oral LD50 around 20 g/kg, which puts it in roughly the same toxicity class as table salt. Keep those two facts in mind and the rest of this comparison falls into place.
The chemistry is similar enough that the choice almost never comes down to performance. It's mostly about where the material will end up and who could come into contact with it. This article walks through the chemistry, properties, applications, safety profile, storage conditions, and environmental footprint of each compound, side by side.
1. Chemical Identity at a Glance
|
Attribute |
||
|
IUPAC name |
Propane-1,2-diol |
Ethane-1,2-diol |
|
Common synonyms |
1,2-Propanediol, MPG, α-propylene glycol |
1,2-Ethanediol, MEG, monoethylene glycol |
|
CAS Number |
57-55-6 |
107-21-1 |
|
Molecular formula |
C₃H₈O₂ |
C₂H₆O₂ |
|
Molecular weight |
76.09 g/mol |
62.07 g/mol |
|
Functional groups |
Two hydroxyl (one primary, one secondary) |
Two primary hydroxyl |
|
Carbon chain |
3 carbons, asymmetric |
2 carbons, symmetric |
|
Carbon backbone |
C–C–C |
C–C |
Both compounds are vicinal diols, which means the two hydroxyl groups sit on adjacent carbons. That structural detail is what gives them their similar solvent behavior. The differences (one extra carbon in PG, plus the asymmetric secondary alcohol) drive the differences in physical properties, metabolism, and toxicity that come later in this article.
2. Physical Properties
The two glycols share most physical properties because their molecular architectures are so similar. The differences that matter, though, are real, and they drive a lot of the use-case decisions.
|
Property |
Propylene Glycol |
Ethylene Glycol |
Practical Note |
|
Appearance |
Colorless, viscous liquid |
Colorless, syrupy liquid |
Both clear; visually similar |
|
Odor |
Practically odorless |
Mild, sweet |
EG's sweetness is a major poisoning risk |
|
Density @ 20 °C |
1.036 g/cm³ |
1.113 g/cm³ |
EG is about 7% denser; affects volumetric dosing |
|
Boiling point @ 101.3 kPa |
188.2 °C |
197.3 °C |
Close enough that both work in mid-temperature systems |
|
Freezing point |
-59 °C (supercools readily) |
-12.9 °C |
PG preferred for very low-temperature fluids |
|
Flash point (closed cup) |
99 °C |
111 °C |
Both Class IIIA combustible liquids |
|
Autoignition temperature |
371 °C |
398 °C |
|
|
Viscosity @ 20 °C |
48.6 mPa·s |
16.1 mPa·s |
EG is about 3× less viscous, easier to pump in cold conditions |
|
Vapor pressure @ 20 °C |
0.13 hPa |
0.07 hPa |
Both low-volatility; minimal inhalation risk at room temperature |
|
Refractive index nD20 |
1.4324 |
1.4318 |
Nearly identical |
|
Surface tension @ 20 °C |
36 mN/m |
47.7 mN/m |
EG wets surfaces more readily |
|
Specific heat @ 20 °C |
2.48 kJ/(kg·K) |
2.35 kJ/(kg·K) |
Similar thermal mass |
|
Thermal conductivity @ 20 °C |
0.20 W/(m·K) |
0.26 W/(m·K) |
EG transfers heat about 30% better |
|
Heat of vaporization |
914 kJ/kg |
1,095 kJ/kg |
EG absorbs more energy per kg |
|
Hygroscopicity |
High |
High |
Both pull moisture from humid air |
|
Water miscibility |
Complete |
Complete |
The practical takeaway: EG has better viscosity, better thermal conductivity, and a lower cost per unit of freezing-point depression. PG has the edge for low-temperature work (anything below -20 °C) and for any application governed by food or pharma regulations.
3. Chemical Behavior and Reactivity
Both glycols behave as polar protic solvents. They dissolve a wide range of polar and moderately polar organic compounds, accept hydrogen bonds, and act as mild plasticizers. They also share most downstream chemistry:
- Esterification with carboxylic acids gives mono- and di-esters. PG esters, notably with fatty acids, are common food-grade emulsifiers. EG esterification with terephthalic acid is how PET is made.
- Etherification with alcohols gives glycol ethers (PGME, EGME, and others), used as coalescing solvents in coatings and printing inks.
- Oxidation by strong oxidizers (chromates, nitric acid, perchlorates) should be avoided in storage.
- Thermal decomposition above roughly 300 °C produces flammable vapors and acrid smoke (acetaldehyde, acetic acid, CO).
Shared incompatibilities: strong oxidizers, strong reducing agents, isocyanates, chlorosulfonic acid, sodium hypochlorite.
4. Applications
4.1 Main uses of propylene glycol
- Food (E-number E1520). Humectant in baked goods, flavor carrier in beverages, plasticizer in chewing gum. Approved by the FDA under 21 CFR 184.1666, by EFSA, and by JECFA.
- Pharmaceuticals (USP / EP grade). Excipient in oral, topical, and injectable formulations, also a carrier solvent for water-insoluble APIs. PG itself is an active ingredient in some drugs (it shows up as a diluent for nitroglycerin, for example).
- Cosmetics and personal care. Moisturizer in lotions, shampoos, deodorants; solvent for fragrances.
- E-cigarette / vape liquids. The dominant base for nicotine solutions. It carries flavor well and gives a smoother throat hit than glycerol.
- Food-contact antifreeze and deicers. Dairy plants, breweries, potable water lines, anywhere incidental human contact is possible.
- Stage smoke and theatrical fog. Vaporized to make a low-irritation aerosol for concerts, film sets, and fire-drill training.
- Unsaturated polyester resins. A building block for marine and construction composites.
- Pet food and animal feed. Moisture retention and palatability.
4.2 Main uses of ethylene glycol
- Automotive antifreeze and engine coolant. Roughly half of global EG demand goes here. Typically mixed 50/50 with water plus a corrosion-inhibitor package.
- Polyester fiber and PET resin. The largest single application, more than 60% of total demand. PET ends up in bottles, textiles, and packaging films.
- Industrial heat-transfer fluids. HVAC, process cooling, geothermal loops, solar thermal collectors, ice rinks.
- Deicing fluids. Airport runways, aircraft, road systems. Often blended with PG near terminals to lower the toxicity risk.
- Hydraulic and brake fluids. Usually as a glycol-ether component.
- Chemical intermediate. Oxalic acid, glycol ethers, morpholine, 1,4-dioxane.
- Printing inks, dyes, leather chemicals. Solvent carrier.
- Explosives and ammunition. Gelatinizing agent for nitrocellulose.
4.3 Where the choice actually matters
Three overlap areas are the ones where mistakes tend to happen:
- Antifreeze and deicers. PG belongs in food-contact or environmentally sensitive zones. EG is the industrial default.
- Heat-transfer fluids. EG when toxicity is controlled and cost matters. PG when leaks could reach food, drinking water, or public spaces.
- Polyester resins. EG dominates PET. PG shows up only in specialty unsaturated polyesters.
5. Safety and Toxicity
Toxicology is what separates these two materials. Even when the chemistry says "interchangeable," the safety profile usually does not.
5.1 Propylene Glycol
Acute oral toxicity (LD50, rat): about 20,000 mg/kg. Classified as "practically non-toxic."
- FDA status: GRAS for food (21 CFR 184.1666).
- Metabolic fate: metabolized by alcohol dehydrogenase to lactic acid and pyruvic acid, both normal intermediates of carbohydrate metabolism. Cleared quickly.
- Skin and eye irritation: mild. Not a sensitizer at typical use concentrations.
- Inhalation: low hazard. High aerosol concentrations can mildly irritate the respiratory tract.
- Therapeutic use: active ingredient or excipient in many FDA-approved oral, topical, and injectable medications.
- Repeated-dose concerns: very high doses, above about 1 g/kg/day orally, can cause lactic acidosis in susceptible individuals. Rare, and well above typical industrial exposure.
5.2 Ethylene Glycol
- Acute oral toxicity (LD50, rat): about 4,700 to 7,712 mg/kg depending on the study.
- Human lethal dose: estimated 1.4 to 1.6 mL/kg body weight. For an adult, roughly 100 mL. For a small child, around 10 mL is enough.
- Metabolic pathway: oxidized by alcohol dehydrogenase to glycolaldehyde, then to glycolic acid, glyoxylic acid, and finally oxalic acid. Oxalate precipitates as calcium oxalate crystals in the renal tubules and causes acute kidney failure within 24 to 72 hours of ingestion.
- Acute symptoms (30 minutes to 12 hours after ingestion): nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, slurred speech, ataxia, nystagmus, metabolic acidosis, hypocalcemia (a consequence of calcium oxalate precipitation). Severe cases progress to seizures, coma, and death.
- Specific antidote: fomepizole (4-methylpyrazole) or ethanol. Both block alcohol dehydrogenase and prevent the formation of the toxic metabolites. Severe cases also need hemodialysis.
- Skin absorption: significant. EG penetrates skin easily. Prolonged or repeated contact with contaminated clothing or gloves can cause systemic toxicity.
- Inhalation exposure limits: OSHA ceiling 50 ppm (125 mg/m³). ACGIH TLV-TWA 25 ppm (vapor fraction). NIOSH REL also 25 ppm.
- Sweet taste: a major risk factor for accidental ingestion by children, pets, and wildlife.
- GHS classification: Acute Toxicity Category 4 (oral, H302); Specific Target Organ Toxicity, repeated exposure, Category 2 (H373).
- Reproductive toxicity: listed under California Proposition 65 as a developmental toxicant since June 2014.
5.3 Toxicity at a glance
|
Endpoint |
Propylene Glycol |
Ethylene Glycol |
|
Acute oral LD50 (rat) |
About 20,000 mg/kg |
About 4,700 to 7,712 mg/kg |
|
FDA GRAS |
Yes |
No |
|
Human lethal dose |
Essentially non-lethal |
About 1.4 mL/kg body weight |
|
Skin permeation risk |
Low |
Significant |
|
Specific antidote required |
No |
Yes (fomepizole / ethanol) |
|
GHS classification |
Not classified as hazardous |
Acute Tox. 4 (H302); STOT RE 2 (H373) |
|
California Prop 65 |
Not listed |
Developmental toxicant |
6. Storage and Handling
6.1 Propylene Glycol
- Recommended containers: stainless steel (304/316), carbon steel with epoxy lining, HDPE plastic, aluminum for short term only.
- Storage temperature: 10 to 35 °C is the practical ideal. PG supercools, so it can stay liquid well below its nominal freezing point. Freezing does not damage the product, but it expands volume by about 1.5%, so leave ullage.
- Moisture protection: critical. PG is hygroscopic and will pull water from humid air, diluting the concentration and shifting the freezing point. Keep containers tightly closed. Nitrogen blanketing is worth it for bulk storage.
- Shelf life: 24 months in original sealed packaging, 12 months once opened.
- Incompatibilities: strong oxidizers (perchlorates, dichromates, concentrated nitric acid), strong reducing agents, isocyanates.
- PPE for routine handling: nitrile gloves, safety glasses, lab coat. Standard industrial hygiene is enough.
6.2 Ethylene Glycol
- Recommended containers: stainless steel, carbon steel, lined steel drums, HDPE. Avoid bare aluminum; EG reacts with aluminum over time, especially with heat, and generates hydrogen gas.
- Storage temperature: 10 to 40 °C. Freezing point is -12.9 °C. Frozen EG expands volume by about 1.6%, so leave at least 10% ullage in drums stored in unheated warehouses in cold climates.
- Moisture protection: less critical than with PG, but still required to keep purity intact.
- Shelf life: 24 months sealed, 12 months once opened.
- Incompatibilities: strong oxidizers, strong acids, sodium hypochlorite, chlorosulfonic acid, oleum. Will corrode plain carbon steel at high temperatures.
- PPE for routine handling: nitrile or neoprene gloves at least 8 mil thick (EG penetrates thin nitrile), splash goggles, chemical apron, closed-toe chemical-resistant footwear. Respiratory protection if ventilation is inadequate.
- Spill response: do not use sawdust or other combustible absorbents. Contain with an inert absorbent such as sand, vermiculite, or perlite. Wash residue with plenty of water and prevent entry into drains, surface water, or groundwater.
- Secondary containment: required for bulk storage under most environmental regulations (40 CFR 264.175 in the US, EU Directive 96/82/EC).
7. Environmental Impact
7.1 Biodegradability
PG is readily biodegradable. OECD 301B and 301F tests show more than 70% BOD/CO₂ evolution within 28 days under aerobic conditions. Anaerobic biodegradation is also documented.
EG is readily biodegradable too. OECD 301B CO₂ evolution tops 90% within 28 days. The degradation pathway (glycolaldehyde to glycolic acid to CO₂) is well characterized.
7.2 Aquatic toxicity
PG: LC50 for Pimephales promelas (96 h) is above 46,500 mg/L, which counts as practically non-toxic to fish. EC50 for Daphnia magna (48 h) is above 43,500 mg/L.
EG: LC50 for Pimephales promelas (96 h) ranges from 18,000 down to roughly 100 mg/L across studies. That puts it in the "not acutely toxic" bucket under standard criteria, but ingestion by wildlife, pets, and birds is still a real-world concern. EC50 for Daphnia magna (48 h) is around 46,000 mg/L.
7.3 Bioaccumulation
Both compounds have a log Kow around -1.4 to -1.9, very low lipophilicity. No expected bioaccumulation in aquatic or terrestrial food webs.
7.4 Carbon footprint (cradle-to-gate, indicative)
|
Pathway |
CO₂e per kg |
|
Petrochemical PG (from propylene oxide) |
1.0 to 1.5 kg |
|
Bio-based PG (from glycerol or sorbitol) |
0.4 to 0.8 kg |
|
Petrochemical EG (from ethylene oxide) |
1.6 to 2.2 kg |
|
Bio-based EG (from sugarcane ethanol) |
0.6 to 1.0 kg |
Bio-based grades of both compounds are commercially available from major suppliers. They cut the carbon footprint by 40 to 60%, but they cost roughly 1.5 to 2.5× as much as the petrochemical equivalents.
7.5 Regulatory status
|
Jurisdiction |
Propylene Glycol |
Ethylene Glycol |
|
REACH (EU) |
Registered (01-2119456809-23) |
Registered (01-2119517215-48) |
|
TSCA (US) |
Active inventory |
Active inventory |
|
DSL (Canada) |
Listed |
Listed |
|
AICS (Australia) |
Listed |
Listed |
|
California Prop 65 |
Not listed |
Developmental toxicant (since 2014) |
|
GHS classification |
Not classified as hazardous |
Acute Tox. 4 (oral); STOT RE 2 |
8. Side-by-Side Summary
|
Attribute |
Propylene Glycol |
Ethylene Glycol |
|
Formula / CAS |
C₃H₈O₂ / 57-55-6 |
C₂H₆O₂ / 107-21-1 |
|
Molecular weight |
76.09 g/mol |
62.07 g/mol |
|
Density @ 20 °C |
1.036 g/cm³ |
1.113 g/cm³ |
|
Viscosity @ 20 °C |
48.6 mPa·s |
16.1 mPa·s |
|
Freezing point |
-59 °C |
-12.9 °C |
|
Boiling point |
188.2 °C |
197.3 °C |
|
Thermal conductivity |
0.20 W/(m·K) |
0.26 W/(m·K) |
|
Flash point |
99 °C |
111 °C |
|
Acute oral LD50 (rat) |
About 20,000 mg/kg |
About 4,700 to 7,712 mg/kg |
|
FDA GRAS |
Yes |
No |
|
Skin permeation |
Low |
Significant |
|
Biodegradability |
Readily |
Readily |
|
Carbon footprint |
About 1.0 to 1.5 kg CO₂e/kg |
About 1.6 to 2.2 kg CO₂e/kg |
|
Relative cost (USD/ton) |
Higher, roughly 2 to 3× EG |
Lower |
|
Primary markets |
Food, pharma, cosmetics, e-cigs |
Automotive antifreeze, PET, heat transfer |
9. How to Decide Between PG and EG
The decision is rarely about performance. Both glycols are excellent solvents and freezing-point depressants. The decision is almost always about regulatory, safety, and end-use constraints.
- If the fluid may contact food, beverages, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, or potable water, choose PG. There is no acceptable substitute for propylene glycol in these applications.
- If the application is automotive, large-scale industrial heat transfer, or polyester synthesis, EG is the economic default, with proper engineering controls in place for toxicity.
- If the application involves potential human contact, pets, wildlife, or environmentally sensitive areas, PG is the right call, even at higher cost.
- If the application is purely industrial and cost-driven (closed-loop cooling in a chemical plant, for example), EG works, with proper secondary containment and disposal controls.
- If you need a freezing point below -20 °C, PG wins, since pure EG freezes at -12.9 °C. EG-water mixtures can go lower, but they need careful ratio control and verification.
10. Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between propylene glycol and ethylene glycol?
Toxicity. PG is GRAS for food contact, with an oral LD50 around 20,000 mg/kg. EG is acutely toxic, with a human lethal dose around 1.4 mL/kg of body weight, and a specific antidote (fomepizole or ethanol) is required if someone is poisoned.
Can I use ethylene glycol in a food-grade system?
No. EG is not approved for food contact under FDA 21 CFR, EFSA, or most national food-safety regulations. Only PG, USP or FCC grade, should appear in any system with potential food or potable-water contact.
Is propylene glycol biodegradable?
Yes. PG is readily biodegradable under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions, reaching more than 70% BOD/CO₂ removal in 28 days per OECD 301 tests.
Why is ethylene glycol used in car antifreeze if it's so toxic?
EG has the best combination of low cost, low viscosity, high boiling point, and good heat-transfer properties. Automotive systems are designed as closed loops with proper disposal, but spills and improper disposal create ongoing environmental and safety risks, which is one reason PG is increasingly used in food-handling and environmentally sensitive applications.
Can propylene glycol and ethylene glycol be mixed?
They are chemically miscible, but mixing them is not a good idea. The blend would not qualify for food-grade certification, and the toxicity of the mix is dominated by the EG component. There is no industrial reason to combine them.
Which glycol has a lower freezing point?
PG, by a lot. PG's freezing point is -59 °C, versus -12.9 °C for pure EG. EG-water mixtures can reach lower freezing points (down to about -50 °C at roughly 60% EG), but that requires careful ratio control and freeze-point verification.
What grade of propylene glycol should I use for food applications?
USP grade (United States Pharmacopeia) or FCC grade (Food Chemicals Codex). Both meet strict limits on heavy metals, residual solvents, and microbial contamination.
What grade of ethylene glycol should I use for industrial coolants?
Industrial-grade MEG (at least 99.5% purity) for closed-loop industrial heat-transfer systems, or antifreeze-grade EG with a pre-blended corrosion-inhibitor package for automotive work.
Is this article a substitute for the supplier's Safety Data Sheet?
No. The numbers here come from publicly available regulatory sources and are intended as a general comparison, not a stand-in for the SDS from your supplier. Always check the current SDS for the specific product and grade before handling, storing, or disposing of either compound.
11. Conclusion
PG and EG are chemically similar diols, but they have different applications and should not be treated as interchangeable. PG is commonly selected for applications involving potential human or environmental contact, including food, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, potable water systems, and deicing. EG is widely used in antifreeze, polyester production, and industrial heat-transfer applications, where its toxicity can be managed through proper handling and safety measures.
The choice between PG and EG depends mainly on the application, safety requirements, performance needs, and overall cost. For applications where toxicity is a major concern, PG is generally the preferred option. For industrial applications where performance and cost are the primary considerations, EG is often more suitable.





