PP and PE: Same Polyolefin Family, Different Repeat Unit
Polypropylene (PP) and polyethylene (PE) are both semi-crystalline thermoplastics polymerised from olefin monomers, so they share the same processing routes, the same very low moisture uptake and the same melt-and-reform behaviour. The decisive difference is the repeat unit. PP is built from propylene (C3H6) and carries a methyl side group on every second backbone carbon; PE is built from ethylene (C2H4) into an essentially linear chain of methylene groups. That single methyl branch reduces chain mobility, alters crystallinity and therefore changes density, melting point, stiffness, barrier behaviour and chemical resistance at the same time.
For converters and raw-material buyers the outcome is simple to state: PP is the stiffer, hotter-running grade, PE is the tougher, lower-temperature grade. Neither resin is universally superior, and the grade, comonomer content and molecular weight distribution usually decide the result more than the polymer family does.
Property Comparison at a Glance
| Property | PP homopolymer | HDPE | LDPE / LLDPE | Typical test method |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Density (g/cm3) | 0.900 - 0.910 | 0.940 - 0.960 | 0.915 - 0.935 | ASTM D792 / ISO 1183 |
| Melting peak (deg C) | 160 - 170 | 125 - 135 | 105 - 125 | ISO 11357 (DSC) |
| Tensile modulus (GPa) | 1.1 - 1.6 | 0.8 - 1.2 | 0.15 - 0.35 | ASTM D638 |
| Continuous service temperature (deg C) | about 100 | about 80 | about 70 | Grade dependent |
| Water absorption, 24 h (%) | < 0.02 | < 0.01 | < 0.01 | ASTM D570 |
| Melt flow rate condition | 230 deg C / 2.16 kg | 190 deg C / 2.16 kg | 190 deg C / 2.16 kg | ASTM D1238 |
| Moulding shrinkage (%) | 1.0 - 2.5 | 1.5 - 3.0 | 1.5 - 3.5 | ISO 294-4 |
Melt flow rate is not transferable between the two families. PP is quoted at 230 deg C under a 2.16 kg load and PE at 190 deg C under the same load, both according to ASTM D1238, so a PP grade of 20 g/10 min and a PE grade of 20 g/10 min behave differently in the melt.
Where PP Performs Better
Heat resistance is the strongest argument for PP. The crystalline melting range of 160 - 170 deg C allows continuous service near 100 deg C, hot-fill packaging, sterilisation and applications that see repeated temperature cycling. Stiffness is the second argument: a modulus of 1.1 - 1.6 GPa (ASTM D638) lets a moulder thin the wall, and isotactic PP tolerates integral living hinges that PE cannot match. Resistance to oils, greases, fats and most alcohols is good, which is why PP dominates containers for lubricants, cosmetics and food fats. Lower density also means more parts per kilogram at equal volume.
Where PE Performs Better
PE keeps its ductility at low temperature and shows better resistance to environmental stress cracking, which is why pressure pipe, geomembrane and cable jacketing are PE territory. LDPE and LLDPE grades give the softness, toughness and sealing behaviour needed for film, liners and flexible laminates. PE also resists acids and bases better than PP in continuous contact. Realistic limits matter on both sides: PP and PE both swell in aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons, both are attacked by strong oxidising acids, and neither should be selected from a data sheet alone when the chemical environment is aggressive.
Sourcing and Processing Considerations
Buyers should fix the specification on measurable parameters rather than on the family name: melt flow rate by ASTM D1238, density by ASTM D792 or ISO 1183, tensile properties by ASTM D638, and Vicat softening temperature by ISO 306 where heat distortion matters. Additives change performance substantially - UV stabilisers and hindered-amine packages decide the outdoor life of PP geotextile and horticultural parts, while nucleating agents raise PP stiffness and clarity. Recycled streams should stay separated: mixed PP and PE regrind is incompatible at the polymer level and produces low-stiffness, low-value mouldings unless a compatibiliser is dosed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which resin has the higher temperature resistance, PP or PE?
A: PP. Its crystalline melting range is about 160 - 170 deg C against 125 - 135 deg C for HDPE and 105 - 125 deg C for LDPE, which is why hot-fill and sterilisation duties are normally specified in PP.
Q: Which material is better for food packaging?
A: Both families contain grades cleared for food contact. PP suits hot-fill, microwave and retort duties, while PE suits freezer storage, flexible film and closures where low-temperature toughness is the controlling property.
Q: How do I compare melt flow index values between PP and PE?
A: Do not compare them directly. ASTM D1238 specifies 230 deg C / 2.16 kg for PP and 190 deg C / 2.16 kg for PE, and HDPE is also quoted at 190 deg C / 21.6 kg for high-load grades, so the numbers describe different melt states.
Q: Which one is stiffer and which one is tougher?
A: PP is stiffer, with a tensile modulus of roughly 1.1 - 1.6 GPa per ASTM D638, while HDPE sits near 0.8 - 1.2 GPa and LDPE below 0.35 GPa. PE is tougher, particularly at low temperature where PP becomes brittle.
Q: Can PP and PE be recycled in the same stream?
A: They can be collected together as a mixed polyolefin stream, but the melt blend is incompatible and yields parts with reduced stiffness and impact strength. Separated PP and PE streams give higher-value regrind.
Q: Which resin is more resistant to chemicals?
A: It depends on the medium. PP handles oils, fats and alcohols better; PE handles acids and alkalis better at ambient temperature. Both swell in hydrocarbons and are attacked by strong oxidising acids.





